Environmental Exposure and Racial Disparities
Executive Summary
"Environmental
Exposures and Racial Disparities" is a racial analysis
of the most comprehensive report to date documenting the
environmental chemicals found in people living in the United
States, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention's
"Second National Report on Human Exposure to Environmental
Chemicals" (National
Report). The National Report includes information on
the concentration of 116 chemicals in Mexican Americans,
Non-Hispanic Blacks and Non-Hispanic Whites. It also establishes
a national baseline for 89 chemicals and updates the national
baseline for 27 chemicals.
If all socioeconomic factors were equal, one might expect
the concentration of environmental chemicals to be evenly
distributed across a U.S. population that is approximately
three-quarters White and one-quarter people of color. "Environmental
Exposures and Racial Disparities" finds that the three categories
where such a distribution is most closely paralleled are
for naturally-occurring environmental chemicals (metals,
phytoestrogens, and PAHs) people touch, eat, or breathe.
However, synthetic chemicals that people touch, eat, or
breathe (such as dioxins, PCBs, phthalates, pesticides,
herbicides, pest repellants, and disinfectants) pose a greater
burden to people of color.
Key findings for each racial group are as follows:
- non-Hispanic Blacks are much more likely to be exposed
to dioxins and polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and are
more likely to be exposed at higher levels;
- Mexican-Americans are much more likely to be exposed
to pesticides, herbicides, and pest repellants and are
more likely to be exposed at higher levels;
- non-Hispanic Whites are much more likely to be exposed
to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and phytoestrogens
and are more likely to be exposed to phthalates at higher
levels;
- non-Hispanic Blacks and Mexican-Americans are much
more likely to have higher levels of less common chemicals;
and
- non-Hispanic Blacks are exposed to the greatest
number of chemicals in the study.
The CDC report is released every two years and will
include findings from studies of people living in special-exposure
situations (e.g., pesticide applicators, people living
near hazardous waste sites, people working in lead smelters).
Summary of findings from "Environmental
Exposures and Racial Disparities"
| Mexican-American |
Pesticides - 26 chemicals
examined. 6 of the 26 are not found in any person. Of
the remaining 20, 6 are widely found. The mean level
of 2 of the 6 is highest in Mexican Americans while
the mean level of the remaining 4 is highest in non-Hispanic
Whites. Of the 14 that are not widely found, the highest
levels of 7 are in Mexican Americans. |
| Herbicides and Pest repellants
and Disinfectants - 9 chemicals examined. 4 of the 9
are not found in any person. Of the remaining 5, 3 are
widely found and had a mean level highest in Mexican
Americans. The 2 that are not widely found are detected
in highest levels in non-Hispanic Blacks. |
| Limited exposure - The
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbon Chrysene is only detected
in Mexican Americans |
| Non-Hispanic
Blacks |
PCBs and Dioxins - 40 chemicals
examined. 21 of the 40 are not found in any person.
The remaining 19 are not widely found. The highest levels
of 18 of the 19 are in non-Hispanic Blacks. |
| Phthalates - 7 chemicals
measured. Of the 7, 4 are widely found. The mean level
of 3 of the 4 widely found is highest in non-Hispanic
Blacks. The highest levels of the 3 that are not widely
found are detected in non- Hispanic Whites. |
| Tobacco smoke - 1 chemical
measured. It is not widely found and is detected in
highest levels in non-Hispanic Blacks. |
| Limited exposure - 5 chemicals
(3 types of dioxins and PCBs, the pesticide Mirex, and
the herbicide 2,4-Dichlorophenoxyacetic acid) are only
detected in non-Hispanic Blacks |
| Non-Hispanic
Whites |
Metal - 13 chemical examined.
2 of the 13 is not detected. The remaining 11 are wide
found. The mean level of 7 of the 11 is higher in non-Hispanic
Whites. The highest levels for 6 of the 11 are in non-Hispanic
Whites. |
| PAHs - 14 chemical examined.
2 of the 14 are not detected. Of the 7 that are widely
found, the mean level in non-Hispanic Whites is higher
in 5. The highest levels for 6 of the 12 that are detected
are found in non-Hispanic Whites. |
| Phytoestrogens - 6 chemicals
examined. The mean level in non-Hispanic Whites is higher
in 5 of the 6. The highest level for 4 of the 6 is in
non-Hispanic Whites. |
| Limited exposure - There
were no chemicals that are only found in non-Hispanic
Whites. |
Other findings: Of the 37 chemicals that are widely found
in all groups, 21 are found in highest concentrations in
Non-Hispanic Whites, 11 are found in highest concentrations
in Mexican Americans, and 5 are found in highest concentrations
in Non-Hispanic Blacks.
There are 6 chemicals that are widely found with a geometric
mean difference between groups exceeding 100%.
Of the 44 chemicals that are not widely found, 25 are found
in highest concentrations in Non-Hispanic Blacks, 11 are
found in highest concentrations in Mexican-Americans, and
8 are found in highest concentrations in Non-Hispanic Whites.
DDT is 1 of 7 chemicals only found Mexican Americans and/or
Non-Hispanic Blacks. No chemical is only found in Whites.
35 of the 116 chemicals are not
detected.
Methodology: The data is drawn from the CDC reports' results
for blood and urine samples collected as part of the National
Health and Nutrition Examination Survey from 1999 - 2000.
For the purposes of the "Environmental Exposures and
Racial Disparities" assessment, lipid-adjusted blood
results and creatinine-adjusted urine results are used.
Such adjustments compensate for individual variation in
blood serum and urine and are considered more accurate than
data that is not subject to such adjustment. Tobacco smoke
is included even though adjusted data is not presented in
the CDC report. "Environmental Exposures and Racial
Disparities" used two sets of adjusted results from
the CDC report: the geometric mean if the chemical was widely
found or, if it was not, the result for the small portion
of the population that showed some exposure.
|